...
written by Ghostmayhem , June 29, 2008

HOLY CRAP!!
Awesome!!

...
written by kirbyfan66 , June 29, 2008

what game for you to review... i'd like E.T. or Zero Wing.

...
written by CrispyYoshi , June 29, 2008

AUGHHHAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA!

XD Nice one.

...
written by Bandpanik , June 29, 2008

haha dude you are freaking badass

...
written by Jimmy278 , June 29, 2008

I was there! That was an awesome day!... Hey! I'm in the video!

...
written by Ghostmayhem , June 29, 2008

PS- That looks like it was the dumbest yet most epic playfight in the history of stupidity.
I suggest E.T. for the Atari 2600
The Nerd says he'll get to it, but get to it FIRST !!
It's his most-suggested-by=his-fans game! (or...whatever...)
PS- I am BEATING myself up for not going to this thing.
I would've, but it's all the way up in NJ, and I had NO IDEA that this would happen...
Couldn't you've sent a message to everyone on the site, or something?
Oh well, it's still Great that your brother filmed it and posted it here.
You thought the AVGN Response was gonna give you traffic? HAH!

...
written by Kintaru , June 29, 2008

most epic.....battle......EVER!!!!!!!!!

...
written by estefan , June 29, 2008

E.T. is considered the worst game of all-time and not even AVGN has reviewed it. So, that would be a good choice.

...
written by ChrisAdg , June 29, 2008

WE'RE ALL GOING TO DIE! The gates to Hell have opened. The Mighty Powers of the Nerd and the Awesome Powers of the critic, their fight shall destroy the Earth.

E.T. would be a good review seeing how the Third Reich was more entertaining than that game.

...
written by jordanhass , June 29, 2008

It's weird, I don't think Captain S had a grudge with you....

But if you want to review a BAD video game, I would recommend trying for something Nostalgic... such as Home Improvement for SNES

or How about Barney's Hide and Go Seek for Sega Genesis.

It's up to you Nostalgia Critic, show the Nerd who's boss!

...
written by masterem243 , June 29, 2008

I recommend something that the nerd hasn't touched. Like The Wayne's World Game, Deadly Towers, or something really lame of that kind of calibur.

...
written by Horribafuckus125 , June 29, 2008

As everyone has said. ET. One of THE worst video games of all time. not only did it help lead to the video game crash of 1983 but it was one of the starters of shitty video games based on movies. If not that then either Cutards revenge ( if you can actually find it) OR Superman 64. two horrible games in their own rights

...
written by doc10 , June 29, 2008

Why don't you review Superman 64?

...
written by Horribafuckus125 , June 29, 2008

my mistake it's Custard's revenge

...
written by HarroSIN , June 29, 2008

Hah, I can see myself.

...
written by Ghostmayhem , June 29, 2008

So it's settled, then.
E.T. would be THE PERFECT review for you, seeing as how (as I already said) the AVGN has about 1000 messages in his inbox (no I'm not implying anything...) telling him to review it 'NOW!'.
If that falls through, or you just don't own an Atari, how about Superman 64?
It's THE NEXT GAME he's doing, and would REALLY be a slap in the face.
Also, the 64 is a much more recent console, and you probably have one already.

...
written by darththoth , June 29, 2008

you should TOTALLY do Superman 64. It's the next game he's doing... but the question is, does it have to be classic?

...
written by snake91 , June 29, 2008

I saw a really bad video of this today taken on someones phone, I'm glad a high quality vid was made

...
written by CyberLink420 , June 29, 2008

EXCELLENT!

The game has to be either Zero Wing or E.T. Either one would be a good choice...or a bad one depending on your perspective.

...
written by Spectere , June 29, 2008

YES YES YES YES YES YES YESSSSSSSSSSSS!!!!! XD

That was nothing short of amazing.

...
written by Jude93 , June 29, 2008

E.T for the Atari 2600. The ultimate in bad video games!

...
written by ScorpiusPro , June 29, 2008

Beyond epic.
This made my day, week, month...prolly not beyond that bc Dark Knight will make July.

...
written by darthragar , June 29, 2008

if i had to request, id make it a little more modern. i would say review Daikatana(the worst Quake/Doom ripoff ever).

...
written by JoPat , June 29, 2008

TOTALLY...WORTH...IT.

...
written by Captain Chris , June 29, 2008

That was ALMOST as great as the Conan, Colbert, Stewart fight! For your game review do Superman 64 or E.T.

...
written by KiloWattKid , June 29, 2008

I can totally see the critic and the AVGN actually having a decent and sophisticated conversation on the phone on what they are going to review

...
written by Sam_the_Redhead , June 29, 2008

Holy shit! Right in the state I live in!

How could I have missed this? D:

...
written by Dbreiden83080 , June 29, 2008

Classic, that is beyond great right there, oh this is a battle that needs to continue for all our enjoyment.

...
written by TyVulpine , June 29, 2008

Game to review: Zelda CD-i

...
written by Sandheaver , June 29, 2008

OMG! That was a brilliant video, and well worth waiting for.

Loved the references to The Good, The Bad and The Ugly. Fantastic!!!

...
written by ChuckNorris01 , June 29, 2008

so good at game

...
written by Horribafuckus125 , June 29, 2008

"BY THE WAY at the end of the Video

it's said NO REVIEW GAME REQUEST !!!

so WHY everybody here is asking one ????"
umm it actually says NOW

...
written by Jakobi , June 29, 2008

that was the greatest thing EVER!!!!

...
written by storage and disposal , June 29, 2008

This is more epic than the upcoming Avengers movie.

...
written by thunderlord12345678 , June 29, 2008

I just love how Captain S is just there, even though he doesn't have anything to do with it.

...
written by tbussard , June 29, 2008

*Sighs deeply*

All this time, I thought that people would stand up and send in games that knock the living daylight out of you, that would make your blood curdle, that would touch upon the very nerve that violently reacts to the uncanny valley of video gaming. "Home Improvement", "Superman 64", hell perhaps even "Mario Teaches Typing". But no...I have a terrible feeling that the majority vote will bring the Nostalgic one to review "ET, The Extra Terrestrial".

Also, best fight scene I've seen in a long time. Props for making the Nerd seem just as epic as you. Very gentlemanly of you.

...
written by forgottenmemoriesfm , June 29, 2008

This is very epic. E.T. and Superman 64 seem to be the most popular. Also those are Nostalgic movies so he might review the same thing also

...
written by AbyssHunted , June 29, 2008

Looking for game suggestions? Well, here are some of the worst games out there: Custer's Revenge, E.T., Daikatana (the PC version), or Superman 64. Keep in mind that some of them may be difficult to find.

...
written by Javet , June 29, 2008

EPIC WIN!

E.T. all the way.

...
written by Griffoza , June 29, 2008

....freakin cool

...
written by Harry417 , June 29, 2008

hotel mario or the zelda games all for the cd-i. I know not many ppl have them, but it would have a good Nostalgia factor as ppl love mario and zelda, but man those games make Rosie O'Donnell look more appealing than them (well, they're maybe not that bad, but damn close).

...
written by Wolfang , June 29, 2008

I'll have to say it:
Please, DON'T review the E.T. game. Yes, I know, this game sucks a lot, but it is short and it won't be enough to beat what the nerd is making.
I suggest you do the review of another game, take any other game, but not E.T.
Just a friend's advice.

...
written by Jave , June 29, 2008

Hey, NC. That was really an epic video. Since Superman 64 and E.T. are too obvious choices for reviewing, why don't you consider doing The Tick for the SNES? You can tie the review with the cartoon, and trust me when I say the game is pure crap.

Give it a try, it'll make a great review.

...
written by Wolfang , June 29, 2008

Oh, and Superman 64 is the next nerd review

...
written by lopez21 , June 29, 2008

wooooo
i didt see that coming !!!:O
i was hoping to see caopitan planet but this is also cool
dont review superman 64 the nerd is doing it.

...
written by branboozle , June 29, 2008

*Head Explodes*

You have to do E.T. by the way.

...
written by Schram , June 29, 2008

Review Superman 64 before the AVGN does....that will crush him.

...
written by Movie-Brat , June 29, 2008

Well, either the E.T. Atari game or a Barney vdieo game for your video game review and cool video by the way.

...
written by sigmafan , June 29, 2008

C'mon guys, E.T. is way too easy for the Nostalgia Critic to play through. He needs a bit of a challenge, a bit of craptacularness in his life that combines movies and Video games. Ah, I got it. He should have to review...Shaq Fu. A lot of references can be made to Steel and Kazaam in this game. All 3 are totally craptacular and aren't worth the mylar or computer chips made for them.

...
written by rattlehead91 , June 29, 2008

Oh my goodness. Nostalgia Critic trying his hand at a shitty video game and Nerd doing another bad movie.

Everyone wins.

...
written by Relick , June 29, 2008

Completely, utterly, and totally epic in all senses of the word! Good luck reviewing a horrid videogame and I'll be rooting for you all the way!

...
written by neezie , June 29, 2008

I'd try The Predator for the NES, it is a great nostalgic movie, but a terrible game that almost ruins the love for that zany movie. Remember that one part where arnold stabs a scorpion off that guys shoulder? well you fight A LOT of scorpions.

...
written by BallsMonkey , June 29, 2008

Jesus Tap-Dancing Christ

That was Epic!

...
written by Matt913 , June 29, 2008

If you want me to be honest, it should NOT be an E.T. review. As stated, it's too short. What would you say? "This game sucks, but everyone already knows that."

You want a bad game to review? Do Superman 64, and do it RIGHT NOW before the Nerd gets a chance to put up his Superman 64 review (which, he has said, is next, although I wouldn't put it past him to roll the theme song, say "It sucks," and roll the credits).

...
written by Dove , June 29, 2008

Yes, I think ET or Superman 64, it has to be better than Nerd's review of the Nostalgic movie he's making. Superman 64 would be better, if you can make it in time though.

...
written by Matt913 , June 29, 2008

Better yet--pick an awesome game to review, like Ocarina of Time. Then just say that it's the worst game ever because "Zelda's hair shouldn't be blond" or some other such nonsense.

...
written by Deadpool47 , June 29, 2008

Would I suggest, "Mario is Missing"? How bout... hmmm... what was an extremely disappointing game adaptation? Someone suggest something the Nerd hasn't done, isn't going to do, and hasn't been suggested 50 million times? *COUGH ET COUGH*

...
written by SuperSonicGoku , June 29, 2008

Aw man. I wish I was there. That OWNED!!!!!

...
written by SMcCall64 , June 29, 2008

This was totally worth delaying the Capt. Planet video.

As for the game suggestion, I'm suggesting "Bebe's Kids" on the SNES since it used to be the butt of some jokes in "Nintendo Power" and because the AVGN hasn't even touched it yet.

...
written by Mr.tron , June 29, 2008

How about Shaq-Fu?

...
written by IAMDeafSoGiveMeADollar , June 29, 2008

Superman for the nintendo 64 !! *shot*

...
written by Raymond T , June 29, 2008

I hope you two realize you have given more entertainment value with this production then most Hollywood producers do with million dollar budget movies!

I mean... TO WAR!!!!

...
written by storage and disposal , June 29, 2008

I suggest finding an old game the Nerd hasn't reviewed. Or if you want to make things more interesting, have the nerd pick your game and you pick what movie he has to see.

...
written by blushapple , June 29, 2008

I would say Superman 64, but Nerd already has that in the works apparently. So yes, I have to say E.T. There might be funnier games out there, but E.T. is the worst. It is a game that even the Nerd will not bring himself to review. A game so bad that I have seen grown men CRY by playing 4 minutes of it. A game that is worse than Mortal Combat, Power Rangers and Batman & Robin, all mixed together. It is that bad. But you will prove your worthiness as the greatest reviewer of all time. Maybe.

...
written by Dran0n , June 29, 2008

The universe could blow up!

...
written by CrazyChimp93 , June 29, 2008

You HAVE to do Superman 64!

Yes, E.T. may have been a terrible game, but Superman 64, while also being a very god-awful game, is next on the Nerd's agenda. Consider this payback for the Wizard! Also, Superman 64, like someone mentioned earlier, is probably on a more available console then E.T.

NOSTALGIA CRITIC FTW!!!!

...
written by Miryr , June 29, 2008

You could really kick him in the balls if you review Superman 64 but you'd have to hurry before he finishes it.

And if not I'd like a review on Fable, it's a good game but with massive flaws, or Saint's Row, but that's just me

...
written by SquarEvil , June 29, 2008

I also vote for ET

...
written by ctooner , June 29, 2008

I havent even seen it yet and I'm super super super psyched!!!!!!!

...
written by DCII , June 29, 2008

A part of me just died I think.

...
written by AlbertWikoWonkavitz , June 29, 2008

DON'T do ET. Do a game that's obscure, but very sucky. Mighty Max for the SNES was the bane of my childhood.

...
written by AVGN , June 29, 2008

Superman64. lol



This is not James

...
written by TimADugan , June 29, 2008

ET is amazingly overrated as a game that needs to be reviewed. I used to own it...it's not that in need of being ripped into. It was horrible, and it single handedly killed the Atari 2600...but there's not much to say about it. We need something NC can really rip into. Something like the SNES version of Revolution X...or anything on the Atari Jaguar.

...
written by Iconbuster , June 29, 2008

Hey since your going to do a recap on captain planet, why don't you review the game to. you could turn that into one video.

...
written by piece of cake , June 29, 2008

The Nerd used his deadly pen attack!!! This means war!!!

...
written by thedjinn , June 29, 2008

Fantastic. Might I suggest going the trick route - perhaps a game that no one will be suspecting? You know the one.

...
written by rameneater , June 29, 2008

Do a review on porky's for the Atari.

...
written by DoXoR , June 30, 2008

As the Great Chester A Bum Says:

"Oh My God This Is The Best Thing I've Ever Seen In My Life"

This is awesome, Can't Wait for the Nerd's Nostalgic Movie Review & the Nostlgia Critic's Crappy Videogame Review!!!

Greetings from Mexico!!

...
written by Psyga315 , June 30, 2008

ET. Not only is it based off the movie, but it's considered by many to be the worst game ever.

...
written by Caliban Don Flamingo , June 30, 2008

Lol this reminds me of the Conan O Brien VS Stephen Colbert VS Jon Stewart feud a while back. Three awesome guys inexplicably hating and beating the crap out of each other. Very funny stuff.

...
written by SuperVillain90 , June 30, 2008

That was kick ass!
Anyways...maybe "Action 52"

...
written by TheDuchess , June 30, 2008

"This is the equivalent of Elvis meets the Beetles; the whole world could explode."

...
written by Jim , June 30, 2008

Yes!!!! This is awesome

...
written by ASP84 , June 30, 2008

twas epic twasn't tit... errr it

...
written by Fairmonkey , June 30, 2008

You should do ones like Night
Trap or the Zelda CD-I's that
actually have some kind of
movie like stuff in them and
they are terrible too

...
written by Harpuia , June 30, 2008

Does it matter what kind of game it is? NES, SNES, PC, Wii, XBox, etc.?

If it's going to be in the AVGN genre, E.T. for sure. If he can just review any game... I'd go with Big Rigs: Over the Road Racing for the PC. That would blow away anything AVGN's done.

...
written by CreativeUsername , June 30, 2008

omfg.. hahahahahaha this is pure awesomeness. but who the hell is that blonde guy?

...
written by erlnotearl , June 30, 2008

ok i think u should do... WHY DON'T YA BEAT HIM AT HIS OWN GAME...... DO A REVIEW OF SUPERMAN 64!!!! AND THATS HIS NEXT REVIEW ON HIS WEBSITE!!!!!..... now get revenge for he reviewed the WIZZARD before u!

...
written by Super Drybones , June 30, 2008

I've got a game that will make the very blood in your veins boil and burst from you skin. The game is called Twin Caliber and while being a hard to find game, it is for good reason.

...
written by Mr Fist , June 30, 2008

Dammit, my head exploded due to the stella awesomeness of that video. I need some time to recover...

...
written by kniddy , June 30, 2008

Well now I didn't expect that

And these some grown ass men LOL

...
written by goldman , June 30, 2008

make a top 11 worst game ever so you can tell him you're 11 times better

...such a good idea...

lol

...
written by Solid_Snake , June 30, 2008

if the Nostalgia Critic, the nerd, and the captain S teamed up....What would their team name be? The Geek Rangers? ....Okay that sounds like a bad spin off show. But seriously this was AWESOME!

...
written by Jackalsblood , June 30, 2008

THIS IS THE MOST EPIC THING IN THE HISTORY OF EPIC!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

...
written by Lotta Cooties , June 30, 2008

OOOOOOOOooh, this is so great!!!
I pissed myself...

Please, do E.T.!!!

...
written by wowviewer , June 30, 2008

lol Nice. When nerd and critic collide.

A game request might be this (not a bad game, just really hard): A Wanna Be the Guy.
If it's a messed up game, then probably go with Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde. Got to tell you, AVGN was so pissed at this game that he didn't went that far in the game. Good luck on your review.

...
written by Sockfilms , June 30, 2008

I'm Getting NERDGASMS! AHHH!
This is so freakin awesome! For a second there I was scared that yall were just going to drop it and forget about it. But Im so glad you didn't, this makes my pathetic life worth living.

...
written by ChadVision , June 30, 2008

Hilarious made me laugh my ass off

...
written by thatkidwithnoglasses , June 30, 2008

NC WINS he had the AVGN Captain S pined
time-(0.45)

...
written by thatkidwithnoglasses , June 30, 2008

you should review Summer Challenge on sega genesis that game SUCK!!!!!!

...
written by Void , June 30, 2008

Just amazing. Really. I think that's why I like Glasses' videos so much. He really DOES like to go one step beyond. Meeting Nerd in real life for the sake of a funny rivalry..

Well, I strongly disagree with E.T. being the choice. There isn't really.. enough of a game there to review from what I've seen.

...
written by BabyImplosion , June 30, 2008

angry video game nerd has said he will be reviewing the superman64. now, wouldnt it be interesting if you did that before him? hmm. hope your ok. looked like a bloody battle. thanks for the video

...
written by SgtSaintWetPaint , June 30, 2008

That was indeed truly epic. The fact Captain S was in it as well added a 10% slice of awesome to this pie of sheer entertainment. Well done Nostalgia Critic, you have done well.

...
written by Ternel , June 30, 2008

Well here are some games you can review that haven't been totally torn to shreds for their levels of suck.

Super Ninja Boy (SNES)
Mortal Kombat Advance (GBA)
Sonic Genesis (GBA)
Enter the Matrix (PS2)
Ballz (Sega Genesis)
Revolution X (SNES)
Hotel Mario (CD-I)
Link:Wand of Gamalon (CD-I)
Zelda's Adventure (CD-I)
Star Wars: The Phantom Menace (PS1)
Shaq-Fu (Sega Genesis)
Make My Video: Kris Kross (Segs-CD)
Action 52 (SNES)

Just a couple ideas...all are a golden turd just waiting to be chewed on -_-

...
written by Sith Lord Sage , June 30, 2008

lol, james is so trying not to laugh his ass off. I say you do E.T.

...
written by Lordifani , June 30, 2008

OMG, this is fuckin' epic!

...
written by ShiksaWithChutzpah , June 30, 2008

LOL, awesome video. I love how James couldn't keep a straight face.

As for video game request, I suggest JAWS for NES. You could double it up with a review of the horrid JAWS movie sequels if you wish.